Essence is one of my favorite brands because they have really affordable and great products and since I liked their gel eyeliner I had to try one of the liquid ones.
I normally use gel eyeliner and an angled brush but when I'm in a rush I find it easier doing it using a pen.
This is not waterproof, but it claims it's long lasting, sometimes when I can't be bothered I just put on eyeliner and not mascara and the time I did it, this actually smudged pretty quickly, so I wouldn't call it extra long lasting , also even if I touched it a little bit it came off.
The tip gets soggy easily and as a result you can't really do a sharp line, on the plus side it's like a real black on the first swsipe so you don't have to go over and over on the same place.
Bottom line, this was a miss for me, i really don't think it's extra long lasting at all as it comes off super easily and by the end of the day I looked like I had no idea how to do a cat eye or like I touched some black eyeshadow and rubbed my eye so I definitely wouldn't repurchase which means I'm still in search of the perfect eyeliner.
Have you tried this eyeliner? What's your favorite cruelty free eyeliner?